The Best 2009 Bowl Season Debate – Four Straight Titles For the SEC… Need I Say More?

January 11, 2010

Read the arguments from Sports Geek and Bleacher Fan about which conference had the best bowl season in 2009.



It saddens me to write this argument today because it means that college football is over. My Saturdays will have a sense of emptiness, as it always takes me awhile to adjust. But, before we officially close the book on the season, The Sports Debates is taking a look back at the bowl season to decide which conference had the best bowl season. Sports Geek will fight for the little guy with the feel good story of the Mountain West Conference while Bleacher Fan will stick to his roots and arguing that the Big Ten had the best bowl season. I am also sticking to my roots and arguing that the MIGHTY SEC had the best bowl season, once again.

Now, on paper, the SEC’s bowl record of 6-4 pales in comparison to that of, say, the Mountain West (4-1). I will grant that the SEC could have had the ugliest loss that I saw all bowl season with South Carolina’s dreadful performance against UConn. But the conference also had some impressive.

To me, the most impressive win was from the Florida Gators. The Gators, with all of the controversy surrounding head coach Urban Meyer, were able to put all of that aside for one night. They absolutely destroyed the previously unbeaten Cincinnati Bearcats, though it is obvious that the Bearcats had distractions with the absence of Brian Kelly. The difference is the Gators were able to use their distraction as a rallying point. Many fans are Tim Tebow lovers and many are Tim Tebow haters. I fall somewhere in between. But his performance in the Sugar Bowl was nothing short of sensational. He was 31-35 for a Sugar Bowl record 482 yards. Time will tell how far Tebow advances at the next level, but there is one thing that cannot be argued: Tebow has left an everlasting mark on college football.

I would be remiss if I did not mention the national champion Alabama Crimson Tide. There has been much debate in the past few days regarding the national champions. Behind the scenes here at TSD headquarters we have loudly discussed whether or not Alabama would have won if Colt McCoy had not gotten hurt. But that’s water under the bridge now. The Tide joined the Gators in defeating a previously undefeated team. Their victory also makes it four consecutive years that the national champion has come out of the SEC, following Florida, LSU, and again Florida.

In addition to these two teams, Georgia and Ole Miss posted impressive wins over Big XII teams, while Auburn and Arkansas were able to win their games in overtime.

Year in and year out, the SEC sits at the top of the college football conference. The conference takes the best shot of its competitors and has not yet been supplanted as the nation’s best conference. Having successful bowl seasons like this one in 2009 – where it boasted two dominant teams at the top – makes
the SEC second to none!

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The Football Feast Winner Debate – SEC Recruits Future Wins From the ACC

November 30, 2009

Read the arguments from Bleacher Fan and Loyal Homer about which teams or conferences won the Thanksgiving football feast over the long weekend.



It’s good to be the SEC right now. National title hopes? Check. Multiple spots in the highly-lucrative BCS games? Check. Dominate the other regional conference? Check. Winner of Thanksgiving 2009’s Football Feast? Check!

Every rabid college football fan knows how important recruiting is. Sure, some college football writers like Sports Illustrated writer Stewart Mandel have indelicate names for these rabid fans, but I call them smart. These types of fans are tuned in; they understand not just how to win game to game but how to build a sustainable program. True fans believe in program building. Fair weather fans worry about games or select seasons. It’s the difference between rooting for a football team and rooting for a football program.

Every rabid college football fan knows that the SEC wiped the floor with the ACC over the Thanksgiving holiday, further complicating the ACC’s attempt to climb back to national relevance with powerhouse recruiting. Most importantly, all of the recruits that were visiting those home SEC games, those intrastate rivalry games, would be fools to choose the ACC school.

The ACC had three opportunities over the weekend to assert itself as a conference that rivaled the talent level and energy of the SEC, and all were extremely important within each state. At each of these games the cream of the recruiting crop in each state was in attendance and observed an SEC whooping.

The first game took place in South Carolina where a 6-5 South Carolina team was hosting an 8-3 Clemson team that already clinched its division and has an opportunity to take a run at a BCS. Clemson had the record, the momentum, and the star in running back CJ Spiller. But the entire team laid a massive egg in a 34-17 loss. The inability to stop the run (223 yards allowed on the ground) and the inability run the ball (net 48 rushing yards) taught an important lesson to lineman and skill player recruits in attendance – if the game is won in the trenches, one team can win and one team cannot. South Carolina’s finest no doubt took note. A seemingly down and out SEC team with a bad record beat an ACC division winner.

Virtually a carbon copy of the South Carolina game emerged in Georgia. The seventh ranked Georgia Tech Yellow Jackets saw senior night ruined at the oldest stadium in college football in the famed rivalry, “Clean, Old Fashioned Hate.” Georgia racked up a 30-24 victory and gave Tech a taste of its own medicine, limiting the Jackets to just over 200 yards on the ground – well below the team’s average – and amassed 339 against the Jackets’ defense. Georgia is one of the premier recruiting states for high school football with two established and elite programs in the state. As good of a coach and a recruiter as Tech head coach Paul Johnson is, it is a tough sell sitting in the homes of some of the elites in Georgia when a clearly inferior Georgia team dominated a supposedly superior Tech team.

Last, in a game I actually believed would be good, Florida dismantled a bad Florida State team. Yet another talent-rich recruiting state – probably the best of the three – saw the SEC team in the rivalry completely destroy the ACC counterpart, this time 37-10. In keeping with the running theme, Florida ran for 311 yards to FSU’s 83.

In all three cases the SEC had a more dominant offensive and defensive line than the ACC did. For the ACC to catch up with the SEC in terms of talent, it has to show improvement between the hash marks, not just at the skill positions. The ACC showed it still has a long, long way to go.

It does not matter that the ACC is better than the Big East, or that some teams in the ACC are better than others as we learned last weekend. There are few weekends – few opportunities – each football season for the ACC to prove to the SEC and the world that it is equal or better than the SEC, and begin balancing out the one-sided recruiting contest. The ACC had a massive opportunity in important, in-state chief rivalry games, and the entire conference blew it. Know the lesson that was taught now, see the results of the lesson on the first Tuesday in February.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!
Bookmark and Share


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.