The Best NFL HOF Class of All Time Debate… Out With the Old, In With the New

August 13, 2010

Read the opposing arguments from Sports Geek and Loyal Homer.

Officially is has only been six days, but in that short time the most recent inductees have already stolen the title of the greatest class ever to enter the Professional Football Hall of Fame.

The class of 2010 includes a hog, a franchise, a dome patrolman, a motor mouth, a defensive genius, and is capped off by the league’s all time leading rusher and receiver. But before we get to the accomplishments of the group’s headliners, let’s take a look at the contributions of its supporting cast.

On the defensive side of the ball, John Randle, Rickey Jackson, and Dick LeBeau wreaked havoc on the field.

In their respective careers, Randle and Jackson combined for 265 quarterback sacks (they rank seventh and tenth respectively on the all-time career sack list). To put that into context, that two-man sack total is more than the entire Jacksonville Jaguars defense could record in the last eight seasons combined (the Jags amassed only 259 sacks as a team since the 2002 season).

While Randle and Jackson were legendary for their play in opposing offenses’ backfields, it was LeBeau’s presence in the defensive secondary that set him apart. Despite the fact that he retired more than 35 years ago, he still claims the eighth most career interceptions in NFL history, with 62 picks to his credit. But, as impressive as that statistic is, it is not the legacy that LeBeau leaves.

LeBeau’s greatest contribution to the NFL was the invention of the Zone Blitz (that’s right, he invented it).

As for the offensive side of things, Russ Grimm was the key player in one of the greatest offensive lines of all time – the Washington Redskins legendary “Hogs” line. Along with his fellow linemen, Grimm helped lead his team to three Super Bowl championships during the 1980s and 1990s.

Then there is Floyd Little, a player that the entire city of Denver should be thanking DAILY. If not for Little, the Broncos would likely have packed up and left town decades ago. Instead, Little helped bring the Broncos back to relevance, and although he played nine seasons for a struggling franchise that never reached a single playoff game during his career, Little managed to earn five different Pro Bowl selections and became the first player ever to lead the league in rushing while playing for a losing team.

While that group of five players is strong enough on its own to stake a claim among some of the greatest classes ever to enter the Hall, this year it is actually the B-side of the 2010 class.

What propels the 2010 class of Hall of Fame inductees into the status of being the greatest class ever is the fact that they are led by Emmitt Smith and Jerry Rice, the most accomplished running back and wide receiver in the history of the league.

Smith and Rice own just about every rushing or receiving record in the league. They have won a collective six Super Bowl championships, 21 Pro Bowl invitations, and both have earned Super Bowl MVP recognition.

From a production standpoint, Rice has caught more passes for more yards and more touchdowns than any player to put on an NFL uniform. Smith owns the same credentials, having rushed more times for more yards and more touchdowns than any player in the history of the NFL.

Emmitt Smith ranks second all-time in total touchdowns scored and total yards from scrimmage. Do you know who the one man is that he sits behind on both those lists? Jerry Rice.

Over the course of their respective careers Smith and Rice combined for a total of 45,119 offensive yards and scored a combined 383 touchdowns. By comparison, that is more production from two men than the combined total of the seven most productive offensive TEAMS in the league last season (New Orleans, Dallas, New England, Houston, Minnesota, Green Bay, and Pittsburgh).

Rice and Smith serve as the icing on the cake for this class of Hall of Fame enshrinees.

On both sides of the ball, and now on the sidelines, the contributions of these seven newest HOFers to the NFL are unsurpassed. Their contributions do not just influence the outcome of the games they played in, but instead influenced the entire NFL. From top to bottom this newest batch of legends comprises the greatest single collection of players ever to be inducted into Canton at one time.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!
Bookmark and Share


The NFL Hall of Fame Class of 2010 Debate – Shannon Sharpe

February 10, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Loyal Homer and Bleacher Fan.



Shannon Sharpe revolutionized the tight end position in professional football. He was the first tight end to compile more than 10,000 yards. Sharpe was selected to participate in the Pro Bowl eight times throughout his illustrious career. When he retired in 2003, he left with 815 receptions, 10,060 yards, and 62 touchdowns in his career – all NFL records for the tight end position at the time. What might just be the most impressive aspects of Sharpe’s incredible career are the three Super Bowl rings. Yet somehow, in spite of all his obvious qualifications, Shannon Sharpe has been snubbed by the Pro Football Hall of Fame not once, but twice.

How can such a prolific player be excluded from the Hall of Fame? He appears to have done everything right. Set records in many statistical categories? Check. Play at an elevated level throughout an entire career, during both the regular season and post season? Check. And, most importantly, win championships? Check, check, and check. So what has this guy done wrong?

Sharpe is obviously a major contender for the honor, hence his two nominations and progress through the rounds of nominee cutting. But why in the world was he not an absolute no doubter the first time around, let alone the second? What other tight end before him was as integral to the passing game for their team(s)? Currently the NFL features several elite pass catching tight ends, like Antonio Gates, Jason Whitten, Tony Gonzalez, and Dallas Clark. These players are extremely important to their team’s offense in the same way that Shannon Sharpe was, but they are not exploring new territory for their position in the way that Sharpe did. He ventured into uncharted territory for his position, where these modern elites are following the trail he blazed. The tight ends of today are elevated in our minds because they stand on the shoulders of Sharpe and his accomplishments. That type of impact on the game deserves commemoration in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.

Some have alluded to Sharpe’s exclusion as simply a byproduct of the caliber of talent he is forced to compete with for entry into the Hall of Fame. Sure, there has been a boatload of talent on the ballots besides Sharpe. But I can think of no one – other than Emmitt Smith and Jerry Rice – who have meant more to their particular position than Sharpe. Each of these players revolutionized the game. There is that word again – “revolutionized.” The only players that have truly made such a dramatic departure from the expectations we have for a position or way of playing deserve preservation in the living memory of the Hall of Fame. But obviously those who actually have the authority to vote have different ideas. My question is, if Sharpe’s accomplishments for his position do not earn him a spot in the Hall of Fame… what will?

Usually when considering a player’s candidacy for the Hall of Fame a great deal of attention is turned to the ability to win championships. Sharpe has done that… three times! We often debate the credentials of some of the greats based on how many rings they have, but that clearly is not the issue for Sharpe. Instead some feel he has benefited from great systems and a great supporting cast. I do not believe this to be the case for Mr. Sharpe because although he won two Super Bowls with the Broncos, one of his three championships came with the Baltimore Ravens – a team not known for offense.

To Hall of Fame voters, I implore you to book Sharpe’s ticket to Canton, Ohio. Maybe you are keeping him out because you did not like his trash talking. Maybe you are keeping him out because you do not like his fashion sense. But it stands to reason that his athletic accomplishments should grant him a spot in Canton. To continue the snub of Shannon Sharpe is arbitrary and capricious, at best.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The NFL Hall of Fame Class of 2010 Debate – Carter Is Getting the Shaft

February 10, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Babe Ruthless and Bleacher Fan.



There were several different ways I could have gone with today’s article. I nearly wrote that I was not sure why linebacker Rickey Jackson was elected into the Hall of Fame. I know I was a young boy when Jackson was in the prime of his career, but even living in the South and watching the Saints a good bit, I could tell you very little about Rickey Jackson. The fact that he was announced as “Randy” Jackson in the official announcement indirectly proves that I am not alone. I really did not want to rain on the Saints’ parade this week, so I am leaving you Saints fans alone! Sports Geek continues to be upset that former Bears great Richard Dent was once again snubbed. However, what really bothers me the most about the inductees is the fact that Cris Carter is not part of the group.

Cris Carter’s story is somewhat well documented, and I wonder if his early off the field reputation is keeping him out of the Hall. After a stellar three year career at Ohio State, Carter was drafted by the Philadelphia Eagles. Carter had constant run-ins with head coach Buddy Ryan and was eventually released before the 1990 season, despite coming off a season in which he scored 11 touchdowns. As it turns out, Carter was heavy into drugs and alcohol during his stay in the city of Brotherly Love, and Ryan had enough of Carter’s trouble.

Where Cartrer’s career really took off, though, was in Minnesota. After three decent seasons, Carter made the first of eight consecutive Pro Bowls in 1993 with Jim McMahon, of all people, at quarterback. Carter posted 86 catches for over 1,000 yards and nine touchdowns. In 1994, Carter caught a then-record 122 passes as the Vikings became an annual playoff team. Year after year, Carter produced similar numbers. As a Falcons fan, I remember seeing a lot of that 1998 Vikings team, as Carter teamed with Randall Cunningham and then-rookie Randy Moss to form an explosive offense. Of course, we all know which team won the NFC Championship that year! At least fans in Georgia remember. Those in Minnesota would like to forget!

For his career, Carter finished with 1,101 receptions of 13,899 yards and 130 touchdowns. As the saying goes, “All he does is catch touchdowns.” He went to the Pro Bowl eight times and was a first or second team All-Pro three times. He was a member of the NFL’s All-Decade team in the 1990s. Folks, those are Hall of Fame credentials. The really disturbing thing is that Carter did not even get consideration in the final group of ten (seven were eventually elected).

Is Carter’s chance at an induction fading away with each passing year? Unfortunately, it sure looks like it. And that is a complete travesty.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.