The NFL Head Coach Hot Seat Debate, Training Camp Edition – Brad Childress… Is It Getting Hot In Here?

July 24, 2009

Read the Bleacher Fan’s argument that the Cincinnati Bengals’ Marvin Lewis is on the hottest seat and Loyal Homer’s argument that the Dallas Cowboys’ Wade Phillips is on the hottest seat.



Anyone who has a brain knows that “retired” quarterback Brett Favre is going to be donning the Minnesota Vikings’ purple and gold for the 2009 NFL season. With that out of the way, allow me to present you with facts point to Minnesota Vikings head coach Brad Childress has his rump planted squarely on the hottest seat in the NFL as training camps open across the country.

Here is the scene up in Childress’ office in Minneapolis:

The scene opens with Brad Childress sitting behind a large, darkly stained wooden desk. Across the desk from Childress is a chair containing a bunch of eggs. A shadowy outline lurks in a darkened back corner of the office.

Childress: “Thank you for coming today.”
Eggs: “It’s our pleasure, we’re really happy to be on board with you this year.”
Childress: “Yea, I really hope this relationship works out. I can’t foresee any issues.”
Eggs: “Us either, that sounds great.”
Childress: “Well eggs, shall we get introductions out of the way?”
Eggs: “Yea, by all means, take it way. But, you can call us Brett Favre.”
Childress: Casually points to the shadows in the corner of the office as a shift in the room’s light reveals what is lurking in the back.”Okay, great. Eggs, er, Brett Favre, meet your basket.” The eggs calmly jump into the basket without a second thought.

and… SCENE!!

Childress has mortgaged his entire future on the success of Favre’s aging right arm. It’s a risky proposition (just as Eric Mangini). Especially for a coach who is an even 24-24 in the regular season during his tenure in Minneapolis, not including an 0-1 record in the post-season after the team lost at home in the first round of the 2008 playoffs to an average Philadelphia Eagles team 26-14. Though the Vikings have progressed under Childress each season (starting 6-10 in his first season, 8-8 in his second season, and 10-6 last year), many believe the talent at Childress’ disposal is well ahead of the results.

Consider the powerful running game headed by former rookie of the year Adrian Peterson, one of the best running backs in all of football. Many believe the offensive line continues to improve despite the departure of aging center Matt Birk thanks to an already solid left side of the line with left guard Steve Hutchinson and left tackle Bryant McKinnie. Highly-touted draft pick Phil Loadholt is expected to start at right tackle and anchor a side of the line that was troublesome last season. First round draft pick Percy Harvin is expected to add needed athleticism to the wide receiving corps, and the heart of last year’s team – the defense – is expected to maintain their level of play.

In the weakest division in football (thanks, Detroit Lions), winning the division should not be a goal, it should be an expectation.

Brett Favre, though, is the key to the entire operation. Childress has bet his future the quarterback situation, since his questionable handling of Tavaris Jackson – and the even more questionable decision to acquire journeyman quarterback Sage Rosenfels – only brings further scrutiny to the quarterback position and Childress’ decision making. Favre must have another great year to secure owner Zigy Wilf’s confidence in his coach. And the definition of “great” has been expanded to include winning the division and the NFC.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


The NFL Head Coach Hot Seat Debate, Training Camp Edition – Wade Phillips Is Feeling The Heat

July 24, 2009

Read Sports Geek’s argument that Brad Childress is on the hot seat and Bleacher Fan’s argument that Marvin Lewis is on the hot seat .



As The Sports Debates has mentioned several times this week, we sure are ready for football to start. We’re ready for the bone crushing hits. We’re ready for pin-point passing accuracy. We’re ready for a breakway run. Heck, we’re even ready to see Ed Hochuli flex his muscles on the field. Expect to see a lot of football debates in the coming months. In fact, we might as well talk football today. It’s a favorite water cooler topic of any fan in any sport. So I ask you, which coach do you think opens the season with the most to prove? Who is on the hot seat the most?

I really like the coach I am arguing for. He seems like a good guy. He’s had to put up with a lot of crap, but unfortunately it goes with the territory. The coach who I think is on the hot seat right off the bat this training camp season is Dallas Cowboys coach Wade Phillips.

It’s not that Phillips has been a bust in Dallas. He has posted a 22-10 record in the regular season. That would be exceptional anywhere else. Heck, he’d be in the conversation when discussing the coaches in the upper echelon of the NFL. But, he’s not coaching just any team. He’s coaching America’s Team.

Two years ago Dallas went 13-3 and had home field advantage in the playoffs. Their second round matchup was against the division rival New York Giants. The Giants won 21-17, deflating the hopes of all Cowboys fans. Much of the blame fell, unfairly, on Phillips. Forget the fact that he led the team to 13 victories. He couldn’t win in the playoffs, which is something Dallas hasn’t done since 1996. Last year, the team fell to 9-7, including a blowout loss to Philadelphia to close the season. It’s a game that put egg on the face of the entire organization for the entire off-season. It’s a game that led to Phillips’ seat getting warmer. There was even speculation that Cowboys owner (as if you didn’t know who the owner is) Jerry Jones was going to bring in Mike Shannahan. But, Phillips withstood the storm and he’s still there.

How long he’s there remains to be seen. The Cowboys are moving into a luxurious new stadium and the Cowboys need to win! Badly! Terrell Owens, the alleged cause of much of the drama last year, has packed his drama and left for Buffalo. But, he also took his big play potential with him.

The onus is on Wade Phllips to get the job done, now. Going 9-7 isn’t going to get the job, and it’s quite conceivable that just making the playoffs won’t be enough to save his job. With the Philadelphia Eagles, New York Giants, and Washington Redskins in the division it’s going to be tough to get to the playoffs. But, that’s what it is going to take to have a chance to save his job.

No pressure Wade!

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


The NFL Head Coach Hot Seat, Training Camp Edition – Who Dey… Think is Going COACH the Bengals?!

July 24, 2009

Read Sports Geek’s argument that Brad Childress has the most pressure to perform early, and Loyal Homer’s argument that Wade Phillips is the man in the crosshairs.



I feel like a kid trying to go to sleep on Christmas Eve! We are just a few short days away from the opening of NFL Training Camps, and while the old adage that ‘every team is undefeated’ may hold true for now, there are several coaches in the league who already find themselves on the “hot-seat.”

Loyal Homer will argue that Wade Phillips of the Dallas Cowboys is the man with the target on his back, and Sports Geek will argue that it is Brad Childress whose head is first on the chopping block.

As for Bleacher Fan, I believe it is Marvin Lewis of the Cincinnati Bengals whose number has finally come up!

The fact that he’s been able to avoid speculation this long is astonishing to me. Let’s be honest, it’s not like the Bengals were a well regarded team when he took over the reigns from Dick LeBeau in 2003, but to say that the team has actually REGRESSED under Lewis’ tenure is a dubious honor that I’m sure he won’t be writing home about any time soon!

Sure, his first three seasons with Cincinnati showed promise. He took the team from a 2-14 record in 2002 and turned in records of 8-8, 8-8, and then 11-5 respectively. The 2005 season also marked the first division championship AND playoff appearance for the Bengals in 15 years. Things were looking promising for Lewis.

Something changed, though, following the knee injury to Carson Palmer in the 2005 Wild-Card game against the Pittsburgh Steelers. The Bengals came into the 2006 season full of promise, but that promise never materialized into success.

Their records for the following three years plummeted, dropping from 8-8 in 2006 to 7-9 in 2007, before finally bottoming out at 4-11-1 last year. All told, in six seasons as the Bengals head coach, Marvin Lewis has only turned in one season with a winning record, and his career record in Cincinnati is 46-49-1 (.486).

Accompanying that severe decline in performance came a string of legal charges against players within the Bengals organization that made Lewis look like the NFL’s real life version of Nate Scarborough. Then came the icing on the cake – Chad Johnson (I refuse to call him by his “new” name). I will give the man his due, he is a top-tier receiver, but he has turned his existence in the NFL into a media circus that has created far more controversy than it has touchdowns. Between the off-field drama around Johnson’s “happiness” with the organization, and his antics on the field, he has become more of a distraction than anything else.

So where does that leave Marvin Lewis? When you consider the personnel issues, compounded by the lack of success on the field DESPITE having players like Carson Palmer, Chad Johnson, and T.J. Houshmandzadeh (who isn’t even a Bengal anymore), it gives off the appearance that Lewis has zero control over the players within his organization. He comes off as a hapless victim, rather than the leader of a professional football team.

Fast forward to the 2009 season, and this year’s training camp… what is Lewis’ solution to these problems? He welcomes even greater public scrutiny by allowing his Bengals to be the focal point of the HBO mini-series Hard Knocks. That means that every decision he makes in the preseason, and every incident that occurs during training camp, will not only be scrutinized by Bengals fans, beat-reporters, and the Bengals organization, but will actually be scrutinized by a national television audience!

How has that worked out in the past? During the return of the series in 2007, the show watched Herm Edwards as he led the Kansas City Chiefs to a record of 4-12 (Edwards was subsequently fired in early 2009). In 2008, the series travelled to Dallas, where they witnessed the preseason hype around the Dallas Cowboys, preseason favorites to be NFC Champions, and who subsequently melted down mid-season and missed the playoffs altogether. Cowboys head coach Wade Phillips barely escaped the season with his job, and his job-security is still very tenuous, as Loyal Homer points out in his argument today.

Between the increased public scrutiny over his every move in this pre-season, the inability to maintain control over the players within his organization, and the abysmal performances turned in on the field over the past three seasons, Marvin Lewis will need to come out of the gates with guns blazing if he wishes to stay employed in the Queen City much longer.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.