The 2010 NCAAB Player of the Year Debate – Contenders Cannot Scale the Wall

March 12, 2010

Read the opposing arguments from Loyal Homer and Bleacher Fan.

It sure is easy to hand Ohio State’s Evan Turner the college basketball national Player of the Year award (especially after Friday’s game-winner), isn’t it? But, if Bleacher Fan is unable to convince anyone of Evan Turner’s greatness, a few sentences of accolades won’t cut it here. The point is, Turner is a great player who had a great season. But he is NOT the ONLY player in college basketball to have a great season – no matter what the talking faces on ESPN and CBS say. While Turner fills up a stat sheet, Kentucky’s John Wall fills up the win column, and is the straw that stirs the drink on a sure-fire number one seed next week.

While Turner’s stats are nice, John Wall has amassed some excellent stats this season as well. He is averaging just under 17 points per game, four rebounds (not bad for a six-foot something guard), and over six assists per game. While he shoots 46 percent from the field, his 33 percent clip from behind the 3 point line is solid, as is his 78 percent accuracy from the free throw line.

Oh, and he’s a 19-year-old freshman in college and the point guard on arguably the best team in the entire country.

Wall’s stats are solid, but his work ethic is too, by evidence of his willingness to use his amazing speed at both ends of the floor. Yes, that’s right, John Wall plays defense. Getting technical for a moment, there is a reason coach’s recruit speed. Wall’s quick lateral movement on the perimeter makes it very difficult to turn the corner on him on a pick and roll, and very hard to beat him back in transition. Going the other direction, Wall is an excellent finisher around the basket in the unlikely event he is not the first person to reach it due to his speed.

Wall makes the other players on the floor better in a way Evan Turner cannot. While Turner is an ISO player for Ohio State – a skill that will serve him well at the next level, especially – Wall makes other players better… and here’s what I mean. It’s not just the direct, easy-to-see stat line where it is super obvious that a player is good for a team based on the number of assists they log. John Wall does not always get the most assists in a game. Often he will make the right pass to start a ball swing to the opposite side of the floor, resulting in a wide open three point shot attempt or an easy entry pass into the post for a high percentage shot. Those types of plays do not show up in the stat line, but they perfectly describe the impact a player like John Wall has on a team.

Wall’s speed and position – point guard – also translate well into a natural leadership role, even for a youngster. Leadership breeds confidence – and confidence breeds clutch shots.

Perhaps the most critical and difficult to replicate aspect of Wall’s game is his ability to make the big play when it matters the most. Wall’s game is not devoted solely to what shots or passes he makes, it is devoted in large part to when he makes them. In short, John Wall is clutch… and not just one time, but many times during the course of the season. Whether it’s a last second layup or a clutch jump shot, Wall does not shy away from the spotlight. He has proven that he is able to make the play when the most is on the line.

Of course Kentucky is a deeper team than Ohio State. Wall definitely has more players with more skills around him that Turner does. Though Wall may not fill up a stat sheet like Turner does, he fills up the coach’s checklist, the win column… and the stat sheet, too.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The 2010 NCAAB Player of the Year Debate – The Naismith Award Belongs to the Buckeyes’ Head-Turner

March 12, 2010

Read the opposing arguments from Sports Geek and Loyal Homer.

The Naismith Award equals the NCAA Basketball Player of the Year award.

The NCAA Basketball Player of the Year equals the best player in college basketball for 2010.

The best player in college basketball for 2010 equals Evan Turner.

Statistically speaking, the 21-year old guard from Ohio State is the total package. Evan Turner, who is practically a walking double-double, averages 19.5 points and 9.4 rebounds per game (both of which are FAR superior averages when compared to Turner’s toughest competition for the Naismith Award, John Wall). In addition to his Big Ten leading point and rebound average, Turner also provides 5.8 assists per game (putting him at second in the Big Ten in that category).

On both offense and defense, Turner’s presence on the court demands full and constant attention from his opponents. He possesses surprising speed for his size, 6-feet 7-inches and 210 lbs, which allows him to be successful at nearly every position on the court.

While Turner’s statistics make an extremely strong case for him as the Player of the Year, it was actually his time OFF the court which demonstrated just how important and impactful Evan Turner has become.

After suffering several broken vertebrae during a game in early December, Turner was forced to miss six games before he could return to the court. At the point when Turner suffered that injury, the Buckeyes were sitting at 7-1, but during the six-game period where Turner was unavailable, they played to a disappointing 3-3 record with losses coming against Wisconsin, Michigan, and Butler. The Buckeyes fell to 0-2 in the Big Ten, and 10-4 overall.

Upon his return, the Buckeyes found themselves once again rolling through their competition, as they would go on to win 14 of their last 17 games and finish on top of the Big Ten with a conference record of 14-4.

As good as Turner’s supporting cast of John Diebler, David Lighty, Dallas Lauderdale, and William Buford are, their performance without Turner on the floor was very telling. During their loss against Butler, they were out-rebounded by the Bulldogs 45-32 (Turner’s 10 rebound average would have surely made a difference). Two weeks later in their loss to Wisconsin, the Buckeyes went 14 of 43 from the field, and tallied only 43 total points in the game (Turner’s 20 points per game would have made a HUGE difference in that performance). Finally, when they lost to Michigan four days after their game against the Badgers, Ohio State once again turned in a terrible second-half performance, shooting only 28 percent from the floor during the final twenty minutes of play (they were only 36.9 percent shooting overall that night).

Simply put, the Buckeyes would be a middle-of-the-pack team without Evan Turner, who is like the little Dutch boy plugging leaks in the dyke. His versatility allows him to fill any role that is needed on the court at any time, whether that position is point guard, shooting guard, forward, or anything else that may be required at a moment’s notice.

Had he not been able to return to play for Ohio State, they would have entered the Big Ten conference tournament with a bubble-team’s hope for reaching March Madness, and an NIT berth as a more realistic expectation. Instead, Evan Turner has almost single-handedly propelled the 24-7 Buckeyes into very serious consideration for a top seed in the national tournament (a case helped even more by the Syracuse loss in the early rounds of the Big East tournament).

There is simply not another player in the country as effective offensively AND defensively as Turner, who possesses the best all-around skills in the game today. It doesn’t matter what it is called – best player, player of the year, most valuable player – Evan Turner is the only logical choice for the Naismith Award in 2010.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The 2010 NCAAB Player of the Year Debate – Cousins is the Real Kentucky Star

March 12, 2010

Read the opposing arguments from Sports Geek and Bleacher Fan.

Obviously, Evan Turner’s journey has been well documented, and if you want more on Mr. Turner, read Bleacher Fan’s argument. John Wall has been heavily hyped from the start of the season, and he has helped lead Kentucky to an outstanding season and a likely #1 seed in the NCAA tournament. He is being highlighted by Sports Geek. However, I’= am going to step outside the box a bit and go a different direction. I believe that Wall’s teammate, DeMarcus Cousins, deserves serious consideration for college basketball’s Player of the Year.

Cousins, who was also heavily hyped himself coming into the season, originally was committed to Memphis, but when coach John Calipari left Memphis for Lexington, Cousins decided to join him in Wildcat Nation. I will admit that I am always a little partial to big guys over guards, and that is the main reason I am siding with Cousins over his teammate. It is a matter of preference, and it was actually addressed in an SEC teleconference this past Monday.

Cousins, who is a bulky 6-feet 11-inches and 270 pounds, is one of two SEC players averaging a double-double (Mississippi State’s Jarvis Varnado is the other). He is averaging 15.9 points per game with 10.1 rebounds per game and has had 18 double-doubles to this point. Not to mention that fact that he is fifth in the league in blocks at just under two per game, even though in every Kentucky game I have watched he has had a far greater impact on opposing shots than the numbers might indicate. On offense he is often impossible to guard. As Arkansas head coach John Pelfrey said, “Physically, one man can’t guard him.”

Just this week, Cousins was named to the all-conference SEC team, and was named SEC freshman of the year… and we can count on more hardware on the national level soon. This was not at all unexpected. In fact, many mock drafts have him being a high lottery pick in the 2010 NBA draft if he declares for the draft, as expected.

I am not going to pretend that I am a big fan of Calipari, because I am not. But he deserves some credit for molding this young team into a favorite for the national championship. Cousins is a huge part of that. Just have to ask yourself who is more valuable to the team, Wall or Cousins? Wall gets all the glitz and glamour because he plays the point guard position, but Cousins has a chance to dominate the game in the paint – and it is usually a chance he takes advantage of. If he gets in foul trouble, Kentucky is an entirely different team. Opposing teams gain an advantage in the paint when driving to the hole and also when crashing the boards. That is what makes him more important.

Solid cases can be made for Wall and Turner. But Cousins has come on strong down the stretch and deserves to be named the national Player of the Year.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.