The Most Devastating NFL Injury Debate – I Feel the Need… The Need for Reed!

August 24, 2009

Read Sports Geek and Loyal Homer’s arguments regarding which players are so vital to their teams that they cannot afford to be lost to injury.



The Baltimore Ravens are not simply students of the “Defense First” philosophy. They do not take the test, they give it! Sure, they have had their share of offensive highlights (running back Jamal Lewis was a 2,000 yard rusher for the Ravens during the 2003 season), but defense has always been the priority.

Since the team’s inception in 1996, the Baltimore Ravens have earned a total of 57 Pro Bowl invitations. Of those 57 invites, only 20 went to offensive players (and 11 of those belong to retired offensive tackle and future Hall of Famer Jonathan Ogden). That means the remaining 37 invitations all went to Ravens defensive players.

When you look at the list of names which account for those 37 defensive invitations, you see players like Hall of Fame safety Rod Woodson (2 Pro Bowls while playing for Baltimore) and future Hall of Fame linebacker Ray Lewis (10 Pro Bowls). Other names on that list are linebacker Peter Boulware, who earned four Pro Bowl selections, and linebacker/defensive end Terrell Suggs and cornerback Chris McAllister, who both account for three invitations.

It is a literal “Who’s-Who” of defensive dominance over the last 13 years of professional football.

Although Ray Lewis is undeniably the leader of this elite group of defensive superstars, there is another man whose play is much more valuable to the organization today than any other player: safety Ed Reed. With Ray Lewis entering his 14th season as a pro, it is safe to assume that his play on the field will begin to decline. He should still be a difference-maker on the field, but at 34 years old he will not be able to maintain the same level of performance that he has shown for the past 13 years. Instead, the Ravens need Reed to step in and take over as the leader of the Baltimore defense. The 2008 season was proof of that fact.

During the first ten weeks of the season, many felt that the Ravens were little more than pretenders. They felt that once the season played out, Baltimore would find itself on the outside looking in. For his part, Reed’s performance was very disappointing (compared to his ridiculous standards), thanks in part to a nagging neck injury suffered during the 2007 season. As a result, the Ravens – whose defense was still led by Ray Lewis – were not expected to achieve much success in the 2008 season.

Heading into their Week 12 matchup at home against the Philadelphia Eagles, the Ravens had a record of 6-4, with the Dallas Cowboys, Washington Redskins, and Pittsburgh Steelers still on the horizon. It was during that game that Reed picked off two passes (leading to the benching of quarterback Donovan McNabb), returning one of them for a touchdown. After that, things suddenly fell into place for Reed and the Ravens.

During the final six games of the Ravens season, Reed made EIGHT interceptions (two each against Philly, Dallas, Washington, and the Jacksonville Jaguars), leading the Ravens on to win five of those remaining games and a Wild Card spot in the AFC playoffs. During the playoffs, Reed picked off two more passes against Miami (scoring another touchdown), bringing his 2008 interception total to 11 on the year (including the postseason). His efforts helped lead the Ravens to the AFC Championship game.

Since being drafted out of Miami by the Baltimore Ravens in the first round of 2002, Reed has earned five different Pro Bowl selections, and was named the Defensive Player of the Year in 2004. He holds records for interception return yards in a season (358), and in 2008 he broke the record for the longest interception return in NFL history (108 yards), surpassing the previous record (also owned by Reed) by two yards.

In addition to defensive dominance, Reed is also a force on both sides of special teams play, and he is the only person in NFL history to return an interception, punt, blocked punt, AND a fumble for touchdowns! In total, he has scored 11 career touchdowns, with three coming from blocked punts, one on a punt return, two as fumble returns, and five scored off of interceptions.

He was the only player to receive a unanimous vote for the 2008 AP NFL All-Pro team, and with a league-leading nine regular season interceptions last year, he was considered a favorite by many to be named the Defensive Player of the Year for a second time.

He has an amazing ability to disrupt plays, both on defense and on special teams. Entire offensive game-plans must be designed around his presence on the field, and his 43 career interceptions, in only seven seasons, are proof that most team’s efforts to avoid Reed still are not enough to keep him from making an impact on the field. He is a very disciplined defender, and seems to always find himself in the right place at the right time.

If the Ravens are going to continue to be the dominant force on defense that they have grown accustomed to over the past 13 years, they will ONLY be able to do it thanks to the continued dominance of Ed Reed. Losing Ed Reed is losing the season!

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


The Most Devastating NFL Injury Debate – The Colts Go As Peyton Goes

August 24, 2009

Read Sports Geek’s argument that Big Ben is someone the Steelers cannot lose to injury while Bleacher Fan argues that the Ravens cannot afford to lose Ed Reed.



Most teams have played two pre-season games to this point, with two more following in the next couple of weeks. The third pre-season game traditionally showcases the starters for at least a half, while the fourth and final game is basically a showcase for the reserves and the guys trying to make the team. Excited yet? I’m sure excited! What is not exciting is the thought of a star player going down due to injury. Which NFL team can least afford to lose their superstar? After careful deliberation, I have decided that the Indianapolis Colts can ill afford to lose quarterback Peyton Manning.

Peyton Manning has been a star in the league ever since he was drafted first overall by the Colts back in the 1998 NFL Draft. He is a beloved figure in the league. People in SEC country absolutely love him. You will even hear Gator fans and Bulldog fans say they have the utmost respect for Manning. Loyal Homer’s mother, who was born and raised in Georgia and is an avid Georgia Bulldog fan, will root for Peyton Manning against the Falcons and it drives me crazy!! The truth is you will not find many people who will say a negative comment about Manning.

In the NFL, Manning has been named MVP three times. Since starting as a rookie, Manning has an overall record of 124-68 (which includes a 7-8 record in the playoffs and a 3-13 record his rookie season.) The offense is built around him. Before the beginning of the 2008 season, Manning had surgery to remove an infected bursa sac in his left knee. The injury caused him to miss a good bit of training camp and all of pre-season. Did he struggle? No, not him individually. He actually won his third MVP.

This year could be one of Manning’s biggest challenges. Gone is longtime Colts wide receiver Marvin Harrison. That is a big hole to fill, as Harrison has been with Manning since the beginning of the Manning Era. Also gone is former Colts offensive coordinator Tom Moore. He has been Manning’s offensive coordinator for his entire career. Together, Moore and Manning developed the hurry up offense for the Colts. In this offense, the team skips the huddle and goes straight to the line. It is Manning’s responsibility to read the defense and call a play that he sees as a successful play. He audibles the play to the rest of the team through verbal and hand signals.

I am not sure any other quarterback in the NFL could do this. He is the unquestioned leader of the team. Can you honestly see Jim Sorgi running the hurry-up offense? That is exactly what would happen if Manning went down with an injury. Sorgi is to Manning what Jason Garrett was to Troy Aikman for years – nothing but a career backup. If Manning goes down, he takes the team down with him. They go from a Super Bowl contender to a mediocre team. Does another team take that much of a fall in a league built on parity. I think not!

If there is a team that cannot afford to have its star go down, it is the Indianapolis Colts.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


The Most Devastating NFL Injury Debate – The Steelers Cannot Afford to lose Ben Roethlisberger

August 24, 2009

Read Bleacher Fan and Loyal Homer’s argument for who they believe is potentially the most devastating injury an NFL team can suffer.



Many NFL teams have important players. However, only a few teams in the NFL would be devastated if they lost their most important player. The writers at The Sports Debates believe there are three teams – and three players – who, more than any other team, would be significantly less effective if the player went down to injury. Bleacher Fan will argue the player a team that least afford to lose is safety Ed Reed (Baltimore Ravens) while Loyal Homer will argue the player is quarterback Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts).

If there was ever an NFL quarterback who knew how to win without winning pretty, it is Pittsburgh Steelers quarterback Ben Roethlisberger. Big Ben debuted in the NFL in 2004, and won two offensive rookie of the year awards. Since then the awards have dried up, sans the one selection to the Pro Bowl in 2007. He just is not a big time stat producer like some of his fellow quarterbacks in the NFL – Tom Brady and Peyton Manning. Instead, Big Ben is a winner. Now entering his sixth season of professional football, Roethlisberger has two Super Bowl rings. Roethlisberger is the league’s most important player.

Ben Roethlisberger has some skills at quarterback, for sure. But, what he has that most lack is guts and instinct. He has a knack for staying in the pocket and taking the big hits to deliver a pass. He will also stick his neck out in order to gain an extra yard or two on a play (or stop a car). He has an uncanny ability to use his feet to create extra time in the pocket while his receivers get open.

Then there is the ability to lead, measured in the NFL by wins and losses. Roethlisberger has an outstanding all-time regular season record as a starter of 51-20. Against the elite teams in the NFL (we’ll define them as follows: Baltimore Ravens, Carolina Panthers, Chicago Bears, Dallas Cowboys, Indianapolis Colts, New England Patriots, New York Giants, Philadelphia Eagles, San Diego Chargers) he has a respectable regular season record of 15-9. Against his division, the AFC North, he has an all-time record of a whopping 22-4. The supposed biggest rivalry on the Steelers yearly calendar, the Cleveland Browns, have never defeated the Steelers in a game Roethlisberger has played in. He has been so dominant in the battle of the steel cities that the Browns are not even considered a rival anymore (at least they are not considered a rival to the Steelers).

Since Roethlisberger entered the league in 2004 the Steelers compiled a record of 56-24. That means that when Roethlisberger starts at quarterback the Steelers have a winning percentage of 72 percent. Basically, they win three of every four games they play when Big Ben starts under center. Without him the Steelers winning percentage is 56 percent. It is the same defense, the same receivers, the same offensive line, the same running backs – but about a quarter fewer wins. Those stats say something about Roethlisberger’s value.

I cannot make a good argument for Roethlisberger being the most important player to a team in the NFL without talking about his playoff performance. He is lifetime 8-2 in the playoffs – having defeated both NFC teams he has ever faced in the playoffs. He has led three playoff comebacks for victories as well.

We must also talk clutch. Of the 59 career win Roethlisberger has piled up as a starter in the NFL, he has led his team from behind in 19 of them. Eight of those wins happened when he led a scoring drive that ended with less than 43 seconds on the clock (that does not include his two overtime wins). That includes the 2008 Super Bowl when he led a scoring drive that notched the go ahead touchdown against the Arizona Cardinals with just 35 ticks left on the clock.

Roethlisberger wins in the regular season, he wins in the playoffs, and he wins by leading when it matters most, as the seconds tick down. In those clutch, last second drives of the game here are the statistics that Roethlisberger has compiled: completes 74 percent of his passes for 737 yards and six touchdowns. That completion percentage is something to behold.

More, when injury speculation surrounds Roethlisberger, everyone takes it very seriously. The mere specter of an injury to the Steelers’ leader causes a frenzy amongst the Super Bowl media and changes preparation for the opponent. In other words, a single injury rumor about Big Ben impacts how a team prepares for the Steelers.

Roethlisberger’s ability to physically do things in the pocket (and out of the pocket), plus trust his unmatched instincts, separates him from the other quarterbacks in the league. He does not have the Brady’s style or Manning’s extreme smarts. He has his guts, his intuition – and his Super Bowl rings. The Pittsburgh Steelers would not be as dominant year in year out without Roethlisberger. If the Steelers lose him, they lose their identity – and their place in the standings.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg!


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.