The Ideal Super Bowl Matchup Debate – Vikings-Jets Presents Best Super Bowl Matchup

January 22, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Loyal Homer and Bleacher Fan about which matchup presents the best possible game for the 2010 Super Bowl.



Finally, though this season has flown by for me, by Monday morning we will all know the Super Bowl matchup. One thing is certain – no matter what teams are matched up on Super Sunday, the game will be fantastic. Each team plays good defense, most teams play good offense. The one team that does not play good offense – the New York Jets – makes up for what is lacking with extremely excellent defense. The Jets are a fascinating team flush with talent and personality. The Minnesota Vikings may not have the personality the Jets have, but they have balance. Each team is dynamic and interesting on and off the field, and the combination would make the ideal Super Bowl matchup in 2010.

Both teams feature the type of characters and personalities that make media week tolerable for fans and media alike. For the Jets, no personality stands out more than outspoken and bombastic coach Rex Ryan. Plenty of writers have talked about how great Ryan’s personality is, and during media week, should the Jets win this weekend, Ryan will get a lot of camera time. For the Vikings, Brett Favre will continue his media magnetism, for better or worse. Should the Vikings win this weekend – which I believe is very likely – Favre’s accomplishments at his age and stage of career are rather amazing, and worth examining through the relentless spotlight of the media.

It is not as if media week suffers from a lack of stories around the teams and players in the Super Bowl, but Brett Favre will also have the chance to face the Jets one season after wearing the team’s jersey. No, the coaching staff is different from when Favre wore green, but the fans remember the excitement his presence promised, and ultimately did not deliver. Should Favre have the chance to deliver a championship to the Vikings, Jets fans – with the troubles seen from their team’s quarterback Mark Sanchez – will be unable to hold back frustrations.

After all of the stars and non-football stories are covered, recovered, covered again, and then slowly beaten to death, the two teams also play a game of football. While these teams present the best sports reporting opportunities, they also present the best possible matchup of football teams.

The Jets are the prototypical successful playoff team in the NFL. The Jets do two things well – defense, and run the football. The Jets had the best defense in the regular season allowing fewer than 15 points every game, and a mere 252.3 yards allowed per game. Amazingly the Jets only allowed 153.7 passing yards per game (a big reason why I feel the Colts will struggle this weekend). The Jets have the best defensive players in the playoffs. The team also runs the ball extremely well and has improved in that department in the playoffs thanks to the efforts of rookie running back Shonn Greene.

The great thing about this potential matchup is that the one offensive strength the Jets have is the one defensive strength the Vikings have. The Vikings only allowed 87.1 rushing yards per game. Sure, Favre and the offense are well balanced and strong, but they have not faced a defense like the Jets yet, either. Yards and points will be a struggle, especially with as poorly as the Vikings and Adrian Peterson have run the football in the playoffs.

This matchup seems like it would a slam dunk against the Jets. Greatness happens in sports when the odds seem to be are at their most obvious. It is in these situations that expectations are certain. These same conditions were present when an improbable New England Patriots team beat the St. Louis Rams, and the countless other close and surprising NFL playoff games. More than any other game the Jets and the Vikings would showcase the best the league has to offer in off the field stories and on the field drama.

Regardless of the outcome of the games this weekend I will watch the Super Bowl. But, the best possible matchup imaginable is between the Vikings and the Jets.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The Ideal Super Bowl Matchup Debate – A Clash of Styles Leaves Us All With Smiles

January 22, 2010

Read the opposing arguments from Sports Geek and Loyal Homer about which teams they believe would create the best possible matchup for the 2010 Super Bowl.



What is the secret to a Super Bowl Championship? The age-old adage is that defense wins championships, but what if that defense is pitted against one of the most explosive and dynamic offenses in the league?

A Super Bowl between the New Orleans Saints and the New York Jets would answer that question. In a classic matchup of vastly different styles, this potential pairing would go a very long way to salvaging one of the most BORING playoff seasons in NFL history!

The New Orleans Saints are led this season by the NFL’s top rated passer, Drew Brees. In 2009, Brees threw for 4,388 yards and a league-leading 34 touchdowns. Most impressive is that Brees can spread the ball around the field to many different receivers. Where most of the quarterbacks who top the passing charts have a teammate who tops the receiving charts (Matt Schaub and Andre Johnson, Peyton Manning and Reggie Wayne, Tom Brady and Wes Welker), the Saints’ top receiver (Marques Colston) BARELY cracks the top 20 in receiving yards.

With the ability to share the offensive love with so many weapons on offense, Brees and the Saints would present a very unique problem that the Jets may not have an answer for on defense.

The Jets have clearly been the most dominant defense in the league all season, which is the primary reason for their postseason success. The Jets have been able to shut down some of the best offenses in the league, including the San Diego Chargers last weekend.

Their formula is a simple one – they play fundamentally sound defense, and force opponents to play perfect football. When combined with the amount of pressure they exert on opposing offenses through an endless barrage of blitzes, playing perfect football becomes very difficult. Philip Rivers found that out the hard way, when he threw an interception to Darrelle Revis late in the last weekend’s game. With that interception, the Jets had all the opportunity they needed, capitalizing on that mistake (like they have done all season), and finishing off the Chargers.

Revis has been the clear leader on the Jets defensively, and has been such a dangerous playmaker in the secondary that he has been able to eliminate the top receiving threats for any opponent. But, the Saints do not really have a top receiving threat. If Revis covers Colston, then Devery Henderson is available, or Robert Meachem.

I mean no disrespect to the rest of the Jets defense, which also features outstanding players like Bart Scott and Lito Sheppard, but Revis is only one guy. As much as he can be a game changer for the Jets, he cannot be everywhere. The Saints might, MIGHT, have enough options to overcome the combined onslaught of blitzing and Darrelle Revis’ secondary presence.

I would LOVE to see the Saints and Jets face off against each other in Miami two weeks from Sunday, because it would truly be pitting the league’s best offense against its best defense.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The Ideal Super Bowl Matchup Debate – Favre Versus Manning…You Know You Want It!

January 22, 2010

Read the arguments from Bleacher Fan and Sports Geek.



For the past two weeks, I have stated my love of the NFL playoffs. Both the wild card weekend and the divisional round weekends really get me excited. But conference championship games are a whole new ball game. You can bet I will be glued to the TV from 3p until roughly 10p Sunday (the weather forecast is calling for a lot of rain in Georgia on Sunday, so that enhances my chances of being able to watch more football!) Both of the games should be very entertaining for different reasons, though being more of a fan of great offense than great defense, I am personally looking more forward to the Saints/Vikings game. But as far as what I think would be the ideal matchup for the Super Bowl in two weeks, I think it is a no-brainer that it would involve the Indianapolis Colts and the Minnesota Vikings.

We have done a lot of debates since our inception that have included Brett Favre in some sense. At the end of 2009, Bleacher Fan wrote that the Brett Favre saga was the story of the year. I wrote an argument awhile back about how I was sick and tired of hearing about that Favre guy!!! Months later, I must admit I have changed my tune a bit on number four. I find myself kind of rooting for the guy. Obviously I rooted for him last week against the hated Cowboys. But in general, it has been fascinating to watch a 40-year-old roughneck come back from retirement (AGAIN) and put a team up on his shoulders and lead them to great things. What this guy is doing is amazing! I think the Vikings have a real shot at closing this season out in style in South Florida. The Vikings are obviously a ratings draw with Favre and I do not think the NFL would have any opposition to Favre being in another Super Bowl, even if it still makes me turn my head sometimes to see him in something other than a Packer uniform.

The Colts, meanwhile, have another guy at quarterback that you may have heard of. Peyton Manning, along with Favre and Tom Brady, are in my mind the face of the NFL and have been for the past decade. With all the hoopla surrounding coach Jim Caldwell’s decision to rest his starters at the end of the regular season, I think it is quite awesome for Caldwell – by nature a quiet person – to be able to stick it to all of his critics. Manning, in my opinion, is one of the most likable guys in sports these days, and it is really hard to root against him. You get the feeling that he really needs another Super Bowl to add to his legacy also.

How awesome would it be to see a Favre versus Manning showdown in Super Bowl XLIV in Miami at newly named Sun Life Stadium? I think it would set records as far as ratings go and yeah, I know we would all probably get tired of the hype leading up to the game. But Manning and Favre, two future Hall of Fame gun slinging quarterbacks that would be trying to win their second Super Bowl each, would be a dream matchup. I sincerely hope it happens! You know you want it too!

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.