The Best Underclassman Going Pro Debate – Disrupting the Establishment

January 20, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Loyal Homer and Sports Geek about who they believe is the best underclassman coming out of college in the NFL draft.

Today’s version of the NFL is clearly one that favors a strong passing offense. For proof, look no further than the four teams that will be competing for their respective conference championships this weekend. Of those four teams, three are led by arguably the best passers in the game today – Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints), Peyton Manning (Indianapolis Colts), and Brett Favre (Minnesota Vikings). In fact, of the 12 teams who reached the playoffs this season, only two (the Baltimore Ravens and New York Jets) did NOT feature a high-powered passing offense.

The undeniable fact is that success in the NFL today comes from prolific passing.

What, then, was so special about the Baltimore Ravens and New York Jets that it enabled them to buck the trend? Neither possesses a “great” quarterback, and neither has an elite wide receiver (although Braylon Edwards likes to THINK he is).

The answer lies with the defense.

What Baltimore and New York have that enabled them to compete as two of the best teams in the NFL (with the Jets only 60 short minutes away from the Super Bowl) is the kryptonite to a prolific passing offense – a disruptive player in the secondary that can neutralize a passing threat. For the Jets, that player is Pro Bowl defensive back Darrelle Revis, and for the Ravens it is Pro Bowl free safety Ed Reed.

The Jets will be playing on Sunday instead of the Chargers for one simple reason – Revis intercepted a pass from another of the NFL’s passing stars, Philip Rivers, late in the game. The Jets were able to capitalize on Revis’ pick, turning it into seven points and swinging momentum into their favor. As for the Ravens, Ed Reed picked Peyton Manning off twice during their playoff game against the Colts, but neither turnover counted. On the first, Reed had the ball stripped from his hands as he attempted to gain return yards after intercepting the ball, and the second was overturned due to a Ravens’ penalty. Who knows what would have happened if those interceptions had not been overturned.

Revis and Reed are examples of how much impact one single player can have for a team on defense. It is not often that a player comes into the league with the potential to have game-changing impact for their team. But, when they do, that player deserves immediate attention. There just happens to be a player of that caliber who will be available in the 2010 NFL Draft – Tennessee free safety Eric Berry.

Berry has made the decision to take forgo his final year as a safety for the Tennessee Volunteers and instead try his hand at the NFL, which is bad news for a lot of quarterbacks! Not only is Berry going to be the best underclassman of the 2010 NFL Draft, but he might be the best out of the entire Draft pool!

Berry has already drawn comparisons to Ed Reed, and Pittsburgh Steelers free safety Troy Polamalu, for his game changing capability. A two-time unanimous All-American, and winner of the 2009 Jim Thorpe and Jack Tatum Awards (both in recognition as the nation’s top defensive back), Berry quickly earned a reputation as the best defensive back in the NCAA.

Like Polamalu and Reed, Berry can play anywhere within the secondary, which makes him exceptionally dangerous in pass coverage. What makes Berry so special is that his combination of lightning speed with very hard hitting makes him just as dangerous in defending the run as he is against the pass. He seems to be everywhere on the field at the same time. In fact, six of his 83 tackles on the 2009 season were for a loss – not bad for a guy who’s supposed to be in the secondary!

He has an uncanny nose for the ball, and he possesses the ability to do very bad things to his opponents when he gets his hands on the ball. His career total of 494 interception return yards is second in NCAA history, and is only seven yards shy of the all-time mark (a number he would have surely passed if he were to return for his final season of college eligibility).

Adding to his resume comes the support of his former college defensive coach, Lane Kiffin, who knows a thing or two about NFL talent himself. Kiffin praised Berry for his versatility on the field, and agrees that Berry will likely be a top-five pick in the upcoming NFL Draft.

In a league where pass-happy offenses and elite quarterbacks get all the headlines, Eric Berry will be an invaluable addition to one lucky team on defense. My only hope is that he falls to the seventh pick. Berry has already proven that he looks good in orange, and my Browns could sure use the help!

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The Best Underclassman Going Pro Debate – The Golden NFL Draft of 2010

January 20, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Loyal Homer and Bleacher Fan about who they believe is the best underclassman coming out of college in the NFL draft.



The deadline for underclassman to declare for the NFL draft has now passed and the list is impressive. I recommend fans of both pro and college football review it. There are some excellent players in the junior class entering the NFL this season.

In some ways underclassman have a much more difficult pathway toward stardom in the NFL. The threshold for success is high – unfair or not – because the talent is so enormous that a senior season is unnecessary. The already high expectations are increased even further because of the need for rookies to contribute right away. Very few players can rise to high expectations like the conditions outlined in my example. The ideal player must have played on a big stage, performed well, and made plays when it counted. When all of those considerations are balanced against the equal importance of physical talent, one player stands out more than the others – Notre Dame junior wide receiver Golden Tate.

Tate may seem on the small side. He is 5-11 and a stout 195 pounds. But he is the prototypical slot receiver in the NFL because he is tough, has great hands, and excellent body control in traffic. He is the type of physical specimen scouts crave, and has the hands quarterbacks covet.

Tate was the recipient of many postseason awards, achievements he earned through performance… not because of where he played or who his quarterback was. Tate was named first team All-American by the Associated Press and was a Walter Camp first team All-American. He of course won the 2009 Biletnikoff Trophy, too.

What earned him the hardware? A season of 93 catches, 1,496 yards receiving, 15 receiving touchdowns, and two rushing touchdowns. He also returned a punt for a touchdown. Few players in college football made the type of impact Tate did, and he will earn his way onto an NFL team as a result. The pick will be high, and the road to success may be tricky depending on which team gets to draft Tate. But Tate will impact the game in a good way early and often.

The pro game is different, and scouts have a good handle on Tate’s potential impact. Receivers must be strong to fight through bump coverage at the line. Since Tate does not yet possess the recovery speed to stretch routes after fighting through a bump, he is an inside receiver. He can use his strength to break through defensive backs and operate within 15 yards of the line of scrimmage. Once he catches the ball the former running back showed many skills in turning small plays into big plays. Tate compares favorably to a player like Hines Ward. Tough, smart, and great after the catch.

While Tate has the receiving skills and physicality to make an impact quickly in the NFL catching the ball, to earn playing time on a good team he must be multi-dimensional as a receiver. In short, Tate must learn to block. His hands are good, he runs sharp patterns, sits in zones, understands how to get open, runs effectively after the catch, etc. But, he has to block.

Tate is not the fastest receiver in the draft. He is not the tallest receiver in the draft. He is likely not the most complete receiver in the draft, either. But, he is one of the best players, and without a doubt the best underclassman. Tate will have an impact early in the season and provide the type of inside receiving talent that complements big play outside threats.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


The Best Underclassman Going Pro Debate – Don’t Take a Pass on Dez Bryant

January 20, 2010

Read opposing arguments from Sports Geek and Bleacher Fan about who they believe is the best underclassman coming out of college in the NFL draft.



These days it seems like most all of the quality juniors in college football bypass their senior season and head for the NFL. Obviously, this is not true, with Cameron Heyward and Ryan Mallet, among others, returning. But when folks like Jevan Snead announce their intention to declare for the draft, it is easy to see why I have the opinion I do. However, only 53 young men declared for the draft early, and here is the final list. Give it a look because there are plenty of recognizable names. Two of those guys, Golden Tate and Eric Berry, are being spotlighted by Sports Geek and Bleacher Fan. However, after looking over the list, I believe that former Oklahoma State wide receiver Dez Bryant is the best of the group.

Now, I am sure by now every reader knows what happened to Bryant this season. He was declared ineligible after three games for lying to an NCAA investigator about his offseason “meeting” with former NFL cornerback Deion Sanders. But that certainly does not diminish what he accomplished on the field.

In his three games this season for the Cowboys, the junior totaled 17 catches for 323 yards and four touchdowns. In 2008, his sophomore year, Bryant had 87 catches for 1,480 yards and an astonishing 19 touchdowns. It was his production that helped Oklahoma State, long an overlooked fixture in the state of Oklahoma due to their Bedlam rivals, become preseason top ten this past season.

Obviously, Tate is more known by the casual fan because he played a lot of his games on national TV. In fact, the casual fans only know about Bryant because of the ineligible situation. But I had the chance to watch Bryant a fair amount over the past couple of years and I think he will be not only the best wide receiver in this group but one of the best players. He has the size (6-2 and 210 pounds) to succeed, something Tate does not necessarily have (5-11, 195 pounds). Bryant has a tremendous punt return capability, and you can bet that he will see some action returning punts at the next level. He also has great hands. Chad Ochocinco is an NFL player that comes to mind immediately when thinking of Bryant, minus the gimmicks. For Bryant’s sake, I hope he ends up mirroring Ochocinco’s career versus a guy like former Southern Cal wide receiver and NFL draft bust Mike Williams, who also had to sit out some time due to eligibility issues.

It appears to be a thin crop at wide receiver in this draft, with Bryant slightly ahead of guys like Tate and Georgia Tech receiver Demaryius Thomas. But Bryant has a chance to really do something at the next level. After all the drama the guy has been through in the past several months, it will be interesting to see if he is able to take advantage of the opportunity.

My Zimbio Blog Directory Sport Blogs - BlogCatalog Blog Directory
Add us to your technorati favorites Digg! Bookmark and Share


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.